AI at workAgenciesDelegation

Overpaying Your Ad Agency? What AI Can Take Over First

FW
Forrest Webber
Founder, Slacked.co
·November 20, 2026·4 min read

If you are asking whether you overpay your ad agency, you probably can't see what the monthly fee buys. That is the real problem. Price is only a problem when you can't connect it to work.

This page won't tell you to fire anyone. It sorts an agency's work into three piles: what an AI can take over now, what it can help with, and what still needs a person. Then it shows you how to test the first pile for a month before you change any contract.

First, find out what you are paying for

Ask your agency for one month of work, listed as tasks with rough hours. Most agencies can produce this. If yours can't, you have already learned something.

Then sort every line into one of these piles.

Pile 1: work an AI can take over now

These jobs follow a pattern, repeat every week and are easy to check:

  • Reporting. Pulling numbers from ads, analytics and your payments tool into one page. An AI can build that page and refresh it on a schedule. We run ours that way.
  • First drafts. Ad variations, post captions, email drafts, product descriptions. A person still picks and edits. The AI removes the blank page.
  • Routine checks. Broken links, missing page titles, slow pages, ads that stopped serving. An AI can check every morning and tell you only when something is wrong.
  • Simple scheduling. Queuing posts that a person already approved.

If most of your bill sits here, you can probably do it yourself with an AI and a few hours of setup.

Pile 2: work an AI can help with

  • Ad testing. An AI can write the variations and read the results. Deciding how much budget to risk is still yours.
  • Search and content planning. An AI is good at listing questions people search for. It is bad at knowing which ones your customers actually ask. You know that.
  • Design. It is fine for quick variations. A brand that has to look like itself still needs a designer's eye.

Pile 3: work that still needs a person

  • Strategy that depends on your business. What you sell next, who you stop selling to and what a customer is worth to you.
  • Relationships. Partners, press and anyone who wants to talk to a human.
  • Judgment calls with money or reputation on the line. Pausing a big campaign, answering an angry review or approving spend.

A good agency earns its fee here. If yours spends most of its hours in Pile 1, that is where the overpaying is.

Test it before you cancel anything

  1. Pick one Pile 1 job, such as the weekly report.
  2. Have your AI do it alongside the agency for four weeks.
  3. Compare them every week. Is it right? Is it on time? Did you have to fix it?
  4. If the AI's version holds up, ask the agency to drop that line, or move it in-house.

Keep a short written list of what your AI may and may not do on its own. We call these permission lanes. A second AI that checks the first one's work before anything goes out also helps. We call that the reviewer pattern.

What we do ourselves

We run a small group of online businesses mostly with AI and show the results in public. Our reporting, routine checks and first drafts run on AI. Strategy, money decisions and anything a customer would want a person for stay with a person. If you want to see how that is set up, start with how to set up an AI team. If a term here is new to you, the glossary explains it in plain English.

Written by our AI operator and checked by our AI reviewer. This is our experience, not a promise of results for your business.

Want more like this? Get full access to all premium articles plus our weekly AI marketing newsletter.

Subscribe for $9/mo
Forrest Webber

Forrest Webber

Founder of Slacked.co. Builds and runs small online businesses with two AI teammates. Featured on Starter Story and Niche Pursuits. Building the future of AI-powered agency services.

Get the full post + weekly newsletter

Join 500+ operators getting AI marketing insights every Thursday. Unsubscribe anytime.